This month, the Tennessee Highway Patrol agreed to pay $70,000 to Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid. In June 2024, a trooper stopped her in Nashville, said he smelled alcohol, and arrested her for DUI. She told him she doesn't drink, and her blood work later came back clean. Fair is the second sober driver to settle with the Tennessee Highway Patrol, after Thomas Manis received $75,000. Tennessee recorded 419 arrests of sober drivers in 2024. One trooper, James Zahn, is accused of arresting nine, including a Nashville woman, a Thompson Station man, and former U.S. Attorney Jane Bondurant. NASA engineer Labreesha Batey, retired FBI veteran Allison Tsiumis, and Bedford County driver Ron LaFlamme have similar stories. In Bedford County, one trooper's 41 DUI arrests were all dismissed.
A 2026 investigation found the same problem in 22 states. Carl Binkley in Alabama and Ammon Fepuleai in Hawaii were arrested despite being sober. So was Nathan Stephens in Kentucky, who blew 0.00 and passed his roadside tests. Kentucky school bus driver Cody Wilson was cleared by blood tests. In Georgia, records show 701 people tested by the state crime lab in 2025 had no drugs in their system, Lenny Daniel among them. In Fresno, police apologized to council candidate Naindeep Singh. A Maryland driver, Levi Trumbull, was arrested despite a sober breath test. A Florida deputy's charge was dropped after supervisors found no legal basis for the arrest.
Some of these drivers have won real money. A federal jury in Iowa awarded Tayvin Galanakis $105,000. Fort Collins, Colorado, paid $500,000 to a veteran arrested after stopping to help at a crash. In Phoenix, newlywed Brianna Longoria blew 0.000 and is now suing over what she says is a DUI arrest quota.
Here in Massachusetts, drunk driving is called OUI (operating under the influence), and police use the same roadside tests: the walk-and-turn, the one-leg stand, and the eye-tracking test. Many drivers don't know these tests are optional. The state's highest court ruled in Commonwealth v. McGrail (1995) that a Massachusetts driver has no legal obligation to perform field sobriety tests. Because they aren't required, a refusal can't be used as evidence at trial. Massachusetts jury instructions also tell jurors they may accept or reject a police officer's opinion about whether a driver was impaired.
The cases above show why that matters. These arrests often rest on things like an odor, “glossy eyes,” or an imperfect step during a roadside test given to someone who is nervous, tired, or has a medical condition. A breath or blood result can show that the officer got it wrong. But by then, the driver may already have spent a night in jail and lost their license.
An OUI arrest is an accusation, not a conviction.
Sources:
- WSMV: THP to pay $70,000 to Stefanie Fair
- WSMV: Sober drivers arrested in 22 states
- Fox 17: 22 sober DUI lawsuits filed in TN (Batey)
- WKRN: Nashville woman sues THP trooper
- Carscoops: Retired FBI veteran's lawsuit (Tsiumis)
- Yahoo: 41 DUI arrests by one trooper dismissed
- Civil Rights Lawyer: Nathan Stephens
- Kentucky school bus driver
- WSB-TV: Georgia sober DUI data
- SJV Sun: Naindeep Singh
- Levi Trumbull (legal blog)
- Osceola deputy
- Iowa: Galanakis verdict
- Carscoops: Fort Collins $500,000
- AZFamily: Longoria lawsuit
- Commonwealth v. McGrail, 419 Mass. 774 (1995)
